To switch commercial insurance brokers in Colorado, you sign a broker of record (BOR) letter that names your new broker, and your new broker submits it to each carrier on your policies. The carrier then deals with the new broker on your behalf, usually after a short waiting period in which your current broker can respond. Some carriers accept the change mid-term and some wait for renewal, so the first step is finding out what each of your carriers allows.
Below, we cover how the letter works, mid-term versus renewal timing, what to ask a new broker, and what to gather before you start. It is written for Denver metro and Colorado business owners who carry policies such as general liability, workers comp, and commercial auto and want a clean handoff.
What a Broker of Record Letter Does
A broker of record letter is a signed statement from you, the named insured, telling a carrier which broker represents you on a policy. Once the carrier accepts it, that broker handles the account with the carrier: quotes, policy changes, certificate requests, and support when you have a claim.
Carriers publish their own BOR procedures, and the details differ. One national commercial carrier’s published guidelines say a commercial letter should be on the business’s letterhead, name the specific policies, carry the signer’s name, title, and date, and never be backdated. The same guidelines say a BOR letter is for an insured who has decided to appoint another broker, not for getting a renewal quote. For a quote only, you give the broker a separate letter authorizing them to approach the carrier on your behalf.
One more point surprises many owners. The same guidelines state that a letter cannot be filed where the new broker does not represent the insurer on the policy. Ask early whether your new broker can already work with each of your carriers.
Mid-Term Switch or Wait Until Renewal
Carrier rules decide this, and they are not uniform. One published carrier procedure honors one broker change per policy term and, for commercial lines, rewrites the policy as a new short-term policy on the change date. Another carrier’s help page says a broker change can only be made at account renewal.
Waiting for renewal keeps things simple. There is no cancellation to calculate and no rewrite to explain, and your new broker has time to work your account before the old policy expires. A mid-term switch can make sense when service has broken down or a problem cannot wait. Before you sign, confirm whether the carrier accepts a mid-term change, whether the policy will be rewritten, and how unearned premium is handled under the policy’s cancellation terms.
Illustrative example, not a client case: a Denver-area contractor has general liability renewing in March and workers comp renewing in August, each with a different carrier. Because a BOR letter identifies the specific policies it covers, the owner can ask the new broker to move each policy as its carrier allows, instead of forcing everything onto one date.
If you have employees, workers comp deserves extra care. Colorado’s Division of Workers’ Compensation says employers with one or more employees are required to carry it, with limited exemptions for some business owners. Line up the new policy’s start date with the old policy’s end date so no day goes uncovered. Our workers comp policies page explains what Colorado requires, and our Colorado workers comp guide covers class codes and experience mods.
When to Start the Process
There is no single deadline, but you need room for three things: your new broker confirming carrier access, any waiting period the carrier applies, and time to pull your documents together. Waiting periods exist so your current broker can respond. One published carrier procedure uses a ten-business-day window, and only the current broker can waive it. Each carrier sets its own window, so ask.
We suggest starting well ahead of renewal, so the waiting period, the quotes, and your review of the options do not collide with the expiration date. If you are already close to expiration, tell the new broker up front so they can plan around it.
Expect the carrier to notify your current broker once it receives the letter, and expect a call asking why you are leaving. A short written note ending the relationship is enough. Also check any written agreement with your current broker for notice terms.
What to Gather Before You Switch
Your new broker can move faster with a complete file. Gather these for every policy you plan to move:
- Declarations pages and policy numbers for each line, with effective and expiration dates
- Loss runs from each carrier, which are the carrier’s reports of your claims history
- Open claim details, including claim numbers and adjuster contacts
- Current endorsements and any additional insured requirements from your contracts
- A list of the certificates of insurance you have issued and who holds them
- Payroll by job classification and recent premium audit results, for workers comp and general liability
- Vehicle and driver lists, if you carry commercial auto
For contractors, certificates matter most during a changeover. General contractors and clients expect current proof of coverage, so ask the new broker how certificates will be reissued. Our guide to certificates of insurance explains how they work, and we place insurance for contractors across the Denver metro area and the rest of Colorado.
What to Ask a New Broker
Put these questions to any broker before you sign a BOR letter:
- Which of my current carriers can you place business with today?
- How do you handle a mid-term change versus waiting for renewal, and have you confirmed each carrier’s procedure?
- Who will be my day-to-day contact, and who handles certificates and claim support?
- How are you paid, and will any policy fees be charged by the carrier or a wholesaler?
- Can you show me my current coverage side by side with what you propose before I sign anything?
For reference, The Brokerage Insurance Group is paid through carrier commission and does not charge agency fees. Some carriers and wholesalers charge their own policy fees, so ask to see any fees itemized on the quote.
Check the license as well. The Colorado Division of Insurance regulates insurance agents in Colorado, and its site includes a Verify a License tool under For Consumers. Look up any broker before you sign.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I switch commercial insurance brokers in the middle of my policy term?
It depends on the carrier. Some carriers accept a broker of record change mid-term, and others process it only at renewal. Some rewrite the policy as a new short-term policy on the change date, so ask your new broker to confirm each carrier’s procedure before you sign.
Does a broker of record letter change my coverage?
A broker of record letter changes who services your policy with the carrier, not what the policy is meant to cover. Carriers handle the change differently, and some rewrite the policy on the change date, so confirm the carrier’s process and review the new policy documents.
Can I undo a broker of record letter after signing it?
Often, for a short time. Many carriers hold the change for a waiting period so your current broker can respond, and a rescinding letter during that period can keep your original broker in place. One published carrier procedure uses ten business days and requires the rescinding letter to be signed by both the current broker and the insured.
Will my current broker be told I am switching?
Yes. Carriers typically notify the current broker when they receive the letter, and many hold the change for a waiting period so that broker can respond. A short written note from you ending the relationship keeps things clear.
Talk Through Your Renewal Dates With a Colorado Broker
If you are thinking about a broker change, bring your renewal dates and policy list. We will walk through what each carrier allows and how the timing would work.
